Is MSC More Expensive than Carnival?

If you have made arrangements to take a cruise, it is important to take some time to determine which cruise line is going to provide the best deal. It’s also important to realize that due to the large number of cruise lines operating today it may be difficult for you to select the best cruise line based on price alone. Carnival Cruise Lines and MSC Cruises are both very successful cruise lines that have a wide variety of destination options for their customers.

These companies will be the focus of our article here.

So, the question is: Is MSC generally more cost effective than Carnival?

In the article below, we will answer this question by looking at these two cruise lines in terms of pricing, and if they recently changed their rates or had any other significant price changes, as well as any special promotions they have currently going on. Thus, you can make an informed decision about which cruise line to pick for your next trip.

Why Comparing MSC and Carnival Prices Matters

When cruising, comparing rates between MSC and Carnival is critically important in order to obtain the best possible cruise deal. You may wish to compare fare rates for the staterooms (passenger accommodations) and search entertainment/recreation options available on the ship. This will assist you in determining the best cruise option.

Currently, both lines have added ships to their fleets, including the newly added MSC World America. The addition of lines will also affect trip rates on these lines. The rates for both lines will vary based upon three variables - the guest's destination, the guest's date of travel, and the discounts available on that date.

MSC Cruises typically markets primarily to international passengers who enjoy European-experience style travel and lower base rates on extended sailings when compared to Carnival. Consequently, their target market will typically be accompanied by fewer children. Conversely, Carnival primarily sells their cruises to families, i.e., family-oriented vacations with amusement undertones. Understanding your cruise line's target market will help you make the right decision in terms of how well your travel needs will be satisfied - i.e., the long-term/exciting amenities of MSC at competitive, lower rates versus the short-term/fun without surprises of Carnival. If you properly compare each cruise line, you should be able to save hundreds of dollars per person while selecting a cruise style that provides you with exactly what you want!

MSC vs Carnival: Price Comparison**

Fares for the latest, standard, 7-day Caribbean cruise (the most sought after cruise for each line) can be found here, using averages from major cruise line reservation sites and data from the cruise lines:

U.S. returns have consistently shown Carnival’s base fare to be lower than MSC’s for departures from the U.S. for short Bahama/Western Caribbean itineraries. Whether any of these cruise lines can close the price difference or eliminate it altogether depends on the cruise itineraries to the Mediterranean, or whether they give very aggressive discounts (early booking, kids sail free). The cost of a 7-night cruise aboard Carnival will continue with an average price of about $1,400 to $2,000* total for two adults (interior), while the purchase price for an interior room on MSC will be $200 to $400* higher (not including any special deals).

Extra Cruise Costs to Know

The true disparity is often found in the extras included. Let's have a look:

Gratuities: Recently, Carnival increased the charge to $17/day* for regular cabins and $19* for suite cabins, while MSC remains at $12.50–$14.50* per person per day. This saves a family of four approximately $100-$150* each week.

Drink Packages: Carnival's Cheers! package is unlimited, but also costs more ($80 - $90/day*). MSC's Premium Extra limits you to 15 alcoholic drinks per day, but is less expensive ($70 - $85*) and includes tips.

Internet Access(Wi-Fi): MSC usually has better value packages than Carnival, but Carnival's internet is reliable, just more costly for streaming.

Excursions and Specialty Dining: Both lines charge extra for excursions; however, Carnival excursions are generally $10-$30* less per head than the same excursion sold by MSC. Specialty dining on MSC tends to be more upscale than on Carnival, with each meal costing anywhere from $25-$75*.

Other Costs: Port fees ($100- $250/person*) are comparable for both lines. Both have included a significant number of basic fees in their advertised price structure, simplifying true comparison of both lines.

Onboard Experience Differences

Carnival provides a fun, laid-back, American experience on cruise ships, whether you are sliding down a waterslide, watching a comedy show, eating at a Guy Fieri restaurant, or relaxing around a pool. MSC takes more of an upscale, European approach with their ship decor, food options, and atmosphere (though they also provide many things for families). Many MSC ships feel newer and modern. Carnival provides high-energy entertainment and large waterparks, whereas MSC has more upscale entertainment options. Carnival serves hearty and casual food onboard, while MSC tends to serve Mediterranean and more gourmet options. For families, Carnival has a legendary kids club and plenty of family-friendly options, while MSC counters this with excellent youth programming and adult-only areas, such as the Yacht Club, that are available for additional costs.

Also Read: List of MSC Cruises Ships by Class, Age and Size

Special Deals and Discounts

Both cruise lines are very competitive with their promotions and regularly have aggressive programs to attract U.S. passengers.

Carnival: Carnival also often has the better value for U.S. based passengers. They provide a second guest at 50% off the normal cruise fare, children cruise free on many sail dates and provide cruise credits as well as great last minute cruises.

MSC: Typically, MSC will provide early booking bonuses (up to 35% off), children sailing free on certain sail dates and recently they have provided great Mediterranean based cruise promotions.

For the latest cruise season (January-March), Carnival will consistently provide better pricing for passengers departing from U.S. ports, while MSC is usually very successful on sailings from Europe. In addition, both cruise lines offer an extensive loyalty program (Carnival VIFP; MSC Voyager’s Club) to provide additional savings on future cruises once you have sailed with them once.

Which Cruise Line has Better Value

Carnival is usually the best option for those who are budget conscious when traveling or a family that is looking for cost-effective means of finding entertainment during their travels. MSC typically has a better overall value package for those who would like to experience a more refined travel experience, with lower gratuities, and have a focus on European itineraries. You should choose Carnival if you are primarily looking for the cheapest base fare and want a party-like atmosphere. If you want your cruise experience to be more elegant and have some flexibility in your choice of itinerary then you should consider going with MSC - especially if you have a deal that allows you to experience MSC at a much lower price than usual.